Page 1 of 2

[TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Mon Jun 02, 2014 8:00 pm
by Akraen
No conclusions or anything here. Need some reliable ET%'s to math it out.

However, this is basically the best gear profile for frost based off hitting 19.3k breakpoint then getting about 19k mastery as well. It's pitted against my scary (nobody is reacting to it well) idea of breaking 2pc and going for the maximum LB breakpoint of 28.4k.

Honestly, I think we're just seeing more of the same trends. No matter at what point we analyze, haste and mastery do consistent tradeoffs. It's sensitive to the ET%'s and I still don't think anyone is going to find a true answer.

Image

I'm breaking 2pc and going max haste because I'm Akraen, no other reason really.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Mon Jun 02, 2014 9:00 pm
by Crabmodem
I was in a flex run the other day rocking like 16k haste affter reading the thread about trying different reforging. I was then kicked from the flex because I was a bad player for wasting haste. I pointed them to this forum and IV and then was laughed at. I find it funny that other classes do not understand that there are mages out there that are trying to get every last little bit from their gear and spec.

I was doing more damage with the monster haste build. and I think I want to go back to be other be damned.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 3:47 am
by Akraen
Next week I will be unleashed:

http://www.askmrrobot.com/wow/gear/cfa7 ... b34b6dc2fd" target="_blank

Yes that's a normal BBoY, my guild is slooooow.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 4:09 am
by Crabmodem
That looks sick. I'm having to reforge into some more haste since the hunters in my guild will not run a spell haste pet

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 7:59 am
by Berlinia
That looks sick. I'm having to reforge into some more haste since the hunters in my guild will not run a spell haste pet
WHAT!? No spellhaste? Slap their faces and make them summon the pet :P

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 8:13 am
by Crabmodem
Well you see their wolf matches the transmog. So they have the wolf out even though I bring the crit.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 10:38 am
by durrtygoodz
Well you see their wolf matches the transmog. So they have the wolf out even though I bring the crit.
Jesus Christ

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 1:59 pm
by Zildijana
Haha, if the raid leader don't make them change pet, there is something really wrong about that team =P /gquit

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 2:00 pm
by Kver
Well you see their wolf matches the transmog. So they have the wolf out even though I bring the crit.
Send them here. We will finish them.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 4:15 pm
by Akraen
I can't run simc at work but curious what happens if this profile gets run, understanding full-well that the APL is wrong:
Spoiler:
mage=akraen
origin="http://www.askmrrobot.com/wow/gear/usa/ ... awn/akraen"
level=90
race=night_elf
role=spell
spec=frost
professions=Blacksmithing=582/Enchanting=600
talents=222221
glyphs=splitting_ice/icy_veins/water_elemental

hands=kalaenas_arcane_handwraps,id=105841,stats=1823armor_1865int_3037sta_930hit_1475haste,gems=320haste_320haste_320haste_120int,enchant=170haste,reforge=hit_mastery
chest=robes_of_the_tendered_heart,id=105440,stats=2962armor_2642int_4324sta_1340hit_2071haste,gems=320haste_320haste_320haste,enchant=80all,reforge=hit_mastery
waist=belt_of_ominous_trembles,id=105515,stats=1666armor_1981int_3212sta_1451hit_1173mastery,gems=320haste_320haste_320haste,reforge=hit_haste
shoulders=spaulders_of_korkron_fealty,id=105557,stats=2221armor_1981int_3212sta_1005hit_1548haste,gems=320haste_320haste,enchant=200int_100crit,reforge=hit_mastery
legs=leggings_of_furious_flame,id=105516,stats=2592armor_2722int_4324sta_1871haste_1793mastery,gems=320haste_320haste,enchant=285int_165crit
head=flameslingers_fiery_cowl,id=105495,stats=2407armor_2642int_4324sta_1340hit_2071haste,gems=sinister_primal_320haste_180int,reforge=hit_mastery
off_hand=juggernauts_power_core,id=105521,stats=1410int_2236sta_954crit_826haste,gems=320haste_60int,enchant=165int,reforge=crit_mastery
feet=boneinlaid_sandals,id=105493,stats=2036armor_2061int_3212sta_1401haste_1360mastery,gems=320haste_60hit,enchant=140mastery
wrists=avools_ancestral_bracers,id=104595,stats=1251armor_1409int_2114sta_954haste_916mastery,gems=320haste,enchant=180int
finger1=signet_of_the_dinomancers,id=104610,stats=1329int_2114sta_890haste_900mastery,gems=320haste,enchant=160int
back=xingho_breath_of_yulon,id=102246,upgrade=4,gems=320haste,enchant=180int
main_hand=arcweaver_spell_sword,id=105550,stats=1155int_1853sta_832crit_703haste_16509sp,gems=320haste,enchant=jade_spirit,reforge=crit_mastery,weapon=sword_2.2speed_6013min_11168max
finger2=extinguished_ember_of_galakras,id=105498,stats=1490int_2236sta_994hit_994haste,enchant=160int,reforge=hit_mastery
trinket2=black_blood_of_yshaarj,id=102310,upgrade=2
neck=ashflare_pendant,id=105539,stats=1606int_2409sta_1221hit_814haste,reforge=hit_mastery
trinket1=purified_bindings_of_immerseus,id=105422,upgrade=4

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 4:55 pm
by Frosted
"wrong" probably isn't the right word for the Frost APL. Most def incomplete though.

Results:

Your profile"439k+/-352 dps
My profile (nowhere near as well geared): 455k+/- 421

I'd have to go through the APL a bit more, but at a really quick glance it doesn't look like it's even 2pc holding an FoF charge, so the difference is probably larger (unless I'm just misreading it and it is doing it)

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 5:34 pm
by Akraen
I'd need it to be a 40-50k dps gap before I'd say 28k isn't worth it because of the other benefits.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 6:30 pm
by Frosted
What other benefits? It's a significant DPS loss, even without the 2pc being in play.

Maybe I'll have some time tonight to add better 2pc camping into play to the frost APL. Lately I've been getting home right as raid starts though >.<

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 6:59 pm
by Akraen
Because fights in SoO, particularly the tougher ones, are not single target and involve a lot of stutter casting and in cases like Thok, extra procs are godly. By all means, quantify those if you can - but a sim output isn't going to show them.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 7:16 pm
by Frosted
Because fights in SoO, particularly the tougher ones, are not single target and involve a lot of stutter casting and in cases like Thok, extra procs are godly. By all means, quantify those if you can - but a sim output isn't going to show them.
You can get an idea by applying latency and using the movement models. I'll run them now.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 7:35 pm
by Charmander!
I wasn't aware SoO fights involved stutter casting since that can be almost entirely avoided with either ice floes or better positioning.

NT multidotting as frost really only applies to protectors and galakras at the current gear level (nazgrim and spoils adds die too fast) and frost NT is weeeeeaaak, plus you lose a ton of procs with NT ticks occuring so frequently if you were to stack wacky amounts of haste.

Fire doesn't multidot NT and frost shouldn't either. Mage sims aren't terribly accurate, but stacking haste is going to continue to produce inferior results as you go beyond reason with it. What is worse is people trying to follow the example of haste stacking and then wondering why their DPS sucks, deciding it must be the spec rather than their stacking of haste to ridiculous amounts.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 7:39 pm
by Akraen
Because fights in SoO, particularly the tougher ones, are not single target and involve a lot of stutter casting and in cases like Thok, extra procs are godly. By all means, quantify those if you can - but a sim output isn't going to show them.
You can get an idea by applying latency and using the movement models. I'll run them now.
Try this one:
Spoiler:
mage=akraen
origin="http://www.askmrrobot.com/wow/gear/usa/ ... awn/akraen"
level=90
race=night_elf
role=spell
spec=frost
professions=Blacksmithing=582/Enchanting=600
talents=232313
glyphs=splitting_ice/cone_of_cold/icy_veins

legs=leggings_of_furious_flame,id=105516,stats=2592armor_2722int_4324sta_1871haste_1793mastery,gems=320haste_320haste,enchant=285int_165crit
shoulders=spaulders_of_korkron_fealty,id=105557,stats=2221armor_1981int_3212sta_1005hit_1548haste,gems=320haste_160haste_160hit_120int,enchant=200int_100crit,reforge=hit_mastery
wrists=avools_ancestral_bracers,id=105591,stats=1296armor_1606int_2409sta_1087haste_1044mastery,gems=320haste,enchant=180int
back=xingho_breath_of_yulon,id=102246,upgrade=4,gems=80int_160haste_60int,enchant=180int
off_hand=juggernauts_power_core,id=105521,stats=1526int_2409sta_1031crit_893haste,gems=320haste_60int,enchant=165int,reforge=crit_mastery
finger1=signet_of_the_dinomancers,id=105606,stats=1526int_2409sta_1023haste_1028mastery,gems=80int_160haste_60haste,enchant=160int
finger2=extinguished_ember_of_galakras,id=105498,stats=1606int_2409sta_1071hit_1071haste,enchant=160int,reforge=hit_mastery
chest=robes_of_the_tendered_heart,id=105440,stats=2962armor_2642int_4324sta_1340hit_2071haste,gems=80int_160haste_320haste_160haste_160hit_180int,enchant=80all,reforge=hit_mastery
feet=boneinlaid_sandals,id=105493,stats=2036armor_2061int_3212sta_1401haste_1360mastery,gems=320haste_60hit,enchant=140mastery
main_hand=arcweaver_spell_sword,id=105550,stats=1155int_1853sta_832crit_703haste_16509sp,gems=80int_160haste_60int,enchant=jade_spirit,reforge=crit_mastery,weapon=sword_2.2speed_6013min_11168max
hands=kalaenas_arcane_handwraps,id=105841,stats=1823armor_1865int_3037sta_930hit_1475haste,gems=320haste_320haste_320haste_120int,enchant=170haste,reforge=hit_mastery
waist=belt_of_ominous_trembles,id=105515,stats=1666armor_1981int_3212sta_1451hit_1173mastery,gems=80int_160haste_320haste_320haste,reforge=hit_haste
head=flameslingers_fiery_cowl,id=105495,stats=2407armor_2642int_4324sta_1340hit_2071haste,gems=sinister_primal_320haste_180int,reforge=hit_mastery
trinket2=black_blood_of_yshaarj,id=105648,upgrade=4
neck=ashflare_pendant,id=105539,stats=1606int_2409sta_1221hit_814haste,reforge=hit_mastery
trinket1=purified_bindings_of_immerseus,id=105422,upgrade=4
====================================================
Also please try this one:
Spoiler:
mage=akraen
origin="http://www.askmrrobot.com/wow/gear/usa/ ... awn/akraen"
level=90
race=night_elf
role=spell
spec=frost
professions=Blacksmithing=582/Enchanting=600
talents=232313
glyphs=splitting_ice/cone_of_cold/icy_veins

legs=leggings_of_furious_flame,id=105516,stats=2592armor_2722int_4324sta_1871haste_1793mastery,gems=320haste_320haste,enchant=285int_165crit,reforge=mastery_crit
shoulders=spaulders_of_korkron_fealty,id=105557,stats=2221armor_1981int_3212sta_1005hit_1548haste,gems=320haste_320haste,enchant=200int_100crit,reforge=hit_crit
wrists=bracers_of_sonic_projection,id=105626,stats=1296armor_1606int_2409sta_1071crit_1071haste,gems=320haste,enchant=180int
back=xingho_breath_of_yulon,id=102246,upgrade=4,gems=320haste,enchant=180int,reforge=mastery_hit
off_hand=juggernauts_power_core,id=105521,stats=1526int_2409sta_1031crit_893haste,gems=320haste_60int,enchant=165int
finger1=signet_of_the_dinomancers,id=105606,stats=1526int_2409sta_1023haste_1028mastery,gems=320haste,enchant=160int,reforge=mastery_crit
finger2=extinguished_ember_of_galakras,id=105498,stats=1606int_2409sta_1071hit_1071haste,enchant=160int,reforge=hit_crit
chest=mantid_viziers_robes,id=105592,stats=2962armor_2642int_4324sta_1706crit_1859haste,gems=160exp_160haste_160exp_160haste_320haste_180int,enchant=80all
feet=boneinlaid_sandals,id=105493,stats=2036armor_2061int_3212sta_1401haste_1360mastery,gems=320haste_60hit,enchant=140mastery,reforge=mastery_crit
main_hand=arcweaver_spell_sword,id=105550,stats=1155int_1853sta_832crit_703haste_16509sp,gems=320haste,enchant=jade_spirit,reforge=crit_hit,weapon=sword_2.2speed_6013min_11168max
waist=miasmic_skullbelt,id=105569,stats=1666armor_1981int_3212sta_1471hit_1138crit,gems=160exp_160haste_320haste_320haste_120int,reforge=hit_haste
hands=montaks_grips_of_scorching_breath,id=105603,stats=1851armor_1981int_3212sta_1353crit_1328haste,gems=160exp_160haste_320haste_320haste_120int,enchant=170haste
head=flameslingers_fiery_cowl,id=105495,stats=2407armor_2642int_4324sta_1340hit_2071haste,gems=sinister_primal_320haste_180int,reforge=hit_crit
trinket2=black_blood_of_yshaarj,id=105648,upgrade=4
neck=ashflare_pendant,id=105539,stats=1606int_2409sta_1221hit_814haste,reforge=hit_crit
trinket1=purified_bindings_of_immerseus,id=105422,upgrade=4
The latter is a crit BiS profile.

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 7:42 pm
by Akraen
wait I linked you the wrong ones

ok updated :)

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 9:37 pm
by Kver
You might want to consider doing that stuff by PM. You should be happy our moderators are temporarily absent :p

Interesting idea though, I wonder how far you are willing to go to make it work. It also makes me wonder what the stat weights for crit are for you in a 3 target fight..

Re: [TC]Just a DPET Chart

Posted: Wed Jun 04, 2014 10:12 pm
by Akraen
You might want to consider doing that stuff by PM. You should be happy our moderators are temporarily absent :p

Interesting idea though, I wonder how far you are willing to go to make it work. It also makes me wonder what the stat weights for crit are for you in a 3 target fight..
I prefer an open dialogue for experimental theorycraft. Gives people an entrance point for further discussion if they have any ideas or criticisms.

Edit: However, spoilers tidy it up a lot!